21 Underrated Romance Anime With Unique Love Stories

Tired of seeing the same romance anime recommendations over and over? If you’ve already watched Your Name, Toradora!, and Fruits Basket, and you’re craving something fresh, you’re in the right place!

This list of 21 Underrated Romance Anime With Unique Love Stories You Won’t Forget is packed with hidden gems, overlooked classics, and unexpected love stories that deserve way more recognition.

From slow-burn romances to fantasy love stories, and even offbeat, unconventional pairings, these anime offer something truly special.

If you love deep emotions, unexpected relationships, and heartwarming moments, get ready to add some new favorites to your watchlist. Let’s dive in!

1. Akkun to Kanojo (My Sweet Tyrant) (2018)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll
🎭 Genre: Romantic Comedy, Slice of Life
📖 Episodes: 25 (Short-format, ~4 min each)

Akkun to Kanojo

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Ever wondered what a tsundere boyfriend looks like when dialed up to the extreme? 

Akkun to Kanojo flips the typical rom-com dynamic on its head by giving us a male lead who is both hilariously cold and distant yet secretly obsessively devoted to his girlfriend. 

Instead of the usual shy or over-the-top affectionate partner, we get Akkun, a guy who insults his girlfriend Non-tan to her face but secretly follows her around like a love-struck puppy.

What Makes It Unique?

  • The over-the-top tsundere behavior that goes beyond typical anime tropes.
  • Non-tan is completely unfazed by Akkun’s cold front, making their relationship oddly wholesome.
  • Short-format episodes make it a quick and easy binge, perfect for casual watchers.

⭐ 7/10 – Great for a quick laugh, but don’t expect deep character development.


2. Akagami no Shirayuki-hime (Snow White with the Red Hair) (2015)

📺 Where to Watch: Hulu, Funimation
🎭 Genre: Fantasy, Romance, Drama
📖 Episodes: 24 + 1 OVA

Akagami no Shirayuki-hime

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Imagine a fairy tale romance with a strong-willed heroine who doesn’t need a prince to save her. 

Akagami no Shirayuki-hime takes the classic Snow White archetype and reinvents it with Shirayuki, a girl who refuses to be treated as a damsel in distress. 

She’s a smart, independent herbalist who escapes an arranged marriage and ends up befriending Prince Zen, a noble who actually respects her agency.

What Makes It Unique?

  • No forced romance, just a natural, slow-burning relationship that grows over time.
  • Shirayuki isn’t defined by romance; she pursues her own dreams and career.
  • The European-inspired fantasy setting makes it a beautifully immersive experience.


⭐ 8.5/10 – A heartwarming romance with a refreshingly independent heroine.


Last update on 2025-03-11 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

3. Adachi and Shimamura (2020)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll, Funimation
🎭 Genre: Slice of Life, Yuri, Drama
📖 Episodes: 12

Adachi and Shimamura

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

If you love slow-burn romance anime with deep character introspection, Adachi and Shimamura is a must-watch

Instead of a typical love story, this series explores the awkwardness, uncertainty, and quiet beauty of first love between two high school girls.

Unlike many yuri anime that rush into romance, this one takes its time, showing how friendship can gradually evolve into something deeper

It’s soft, emotional, and full of subtle yet powerful moments.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A realistic, slow-building relationship rather than a dramatic, trope-heavy romance.
  • Deep character study of both Adachi (who struggles with social anxiety) and Shimamura (who is emotionally distant).
  • Gorgeous, dreamlike visuals that enhance the melancholic yet hopeful atmosphere.


⭐ 9/10 – Beautifully written and emotionally gripping, but very slow-paced.


4. As Miss Beelzebub Likes (2018)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll
🎭 Genre: Comedy, Fantasy, Romance
📖 Episodes: 12

As Miss Beelzebub Likes

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

A romance anime set in the demon world… but instead of dark and edgy themes, it’s cute, fluffy, and wholesome?! 

As Miss Beelzebub Likes introduces us to Beelzebub, the ruler of Pandemonium, who turns out to be… a soft-spoken, airheaded girl obsessed with fluffy things.

Her assistant, Mullin, starts off as a strict, serious worker but quickly finds himself hopelessly flustered by Beelzebub’s unexpected cuteness

Their office romance in the underworld is a hilarious mix of misunderstandings, soft moments, and pure serotonin-inducing fluff.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A fantasy setting with a heartwarming romance instead of the usual dark themes.
  • Beelzebub isn’t a typical powerful ruler, her love for cute things is both hilarious and endearing.
  • The innocent, wholesome romance is refreshing compared to more dramatic love stories.


⭐ 8/10 – Great for wholesome vibes, but not for those wanting deep storytelling.


5. Bibliophile Princess (2022)

📺 Where to Watch: HIDIVE
🎭 Genre: Historical, Romance, Drama
📖 Episodes: 12

Bibliophile Princess

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Arranged marriages in anime often lead to forced romance tropes, but Bibliophile Princess flips that by making Elianna Bernstein a protagonist who initially agrees to her engagement for access to the royal library rather than love. 

Prince Christopher, however, has his own reasons for choosing her, and as their relationship evolves, she begins to uncover political intrigue, court drama, and her own growing feelings.

The romance is gentle and cerebral, with a slow-burn dynamic that focuses on mutual understanding and respect rather than instant attraction.

What Makes It Unique?

  • An arranged marriage story where love develops naturally over time.
  • Court politics and mystery elements add depth beyond just the romance.
  • Elianna isn’t a helpless noblewoman, her passion for books and knowledge makes her a strong and intelligent protagonist.


⭐ 8.5/10 – A sophisticated romance perfect for fans of historical anime.


6. Boarding School Juliet (2018)

📺 Where to Watch: Amazon Prime Video
🎭 Genre: Action, Comedy, Romance
📖 Episodes: 12

Boarding School Juliet

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

If you love forbidden romance with a dose of comedy, Boarding School Juliet is a fun, modern take on Romeo & Juliet, but with more battle shenanigans and school rivalry.

Romio Inuzuka and Juliet Persia lead opposing school factions that have been at odds for generations, yet secretly, they are deeply in love. 

Their struggle to keep their romance a secret while dealing with student politics and wild school fights makes for an exciting mix of romance, action, and humor.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A fast-paced, high-energy romance where the leads are actively hiding their relationship.
  • Hilarious misunderstandings and exaggerated fight sequences give it an almost Shonen Jump feel.
  • Romio and Juliet are equal partners, both fighting to create a world where they can be together.


⭐ 8/10 – A great choice for fans of rom-coms with an extra punch (literally).


7. Code: Realize Guardian of Rebirth (2017)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll
🎭 Genre: Fantasy, Steampunk, Romance
📖 Episodes: 12

Code: Realize Guardian of Rebirth

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Steampunk romance anime are rare, and Code: Realize offers a beautifully designed world inspired by Victorian London, with characters based on classic literary figures

The story follows Cardia, a girl whose body secretes a deadly poison, making human contact impossible. She is rescued by Arsène Lupin, a charming gentleman thief, who promises to help her uncover the secrets of her past.

This anime is a blend of mystery, action, and romance, with a visual novel-esque storytelling style where Cardia slowly builds trust and emotional connections despite her cursed existence.

What Makes It Unique?

  • Romance meets steampunk adventure, creating a fresh and stylish aesthetic.
  • Features historical and literary characters like Victor Frankenstein, Van Helsing, and Lupin.
  • A strong heroine learning to love and trust despite her dangerous condition.


⭐ 8/10 – A stunning blend of adventure and romance with a touch of mystery.


8. Endo and Kobayashi Live! The Latest on Tsundere Villainess Lieselotte (2023)

📺 Where to Watch: HIDIVE
🎭 Genre: Fantasy, Comedy, Romance
📖 Episodes: 12

Endo and Kobayashi Live! The Latest on Tsundere Villainess Lieselotte

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Have you ever yelled at a video game character, wishing they could hear you? Well, in Endo and Kobayashi Live!, that’s exactly what happens

Two high school students, Endo and Kobayashi, start commentating on an otome game, only to discover that the characters inside the game can actually hear them!

What follows is a hilarious and heartwarming story where the protagonists attempt to change the fate of Lieselotte, the so-called “villainess”, by guiding the prince (her love interest) in real-time.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A meta take on otome games, like Re:Zero meets My Next Life as a Villainess.
  • Lieselotte isn’t actually a villainess, she’s a misunderstood, socially awkward girl.
  • Two narratives intertwining: One inside the game, and one in the real world.


⭐ 8.5/10 – A delightful mix of humor, romance, and unique storytelling.


9. Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun (Monthly Girls’ Nozaki-kun) (2014)

📺 Where to Watch: HIDIVE
🎭 Genre: Romantic Comedy, Slice of Life, Parody
📖 Episodes: 12

Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Imagine confessing to your crush, only for him to hand you an autograph instead of a love confession, because he’s a manga artist and thinks you’re just a fan

That’s exactly what happens to Chiyo Sakura, who has a massive crush on her dense but lovable classmate Nozaki, who happens to be a popular shoujo manga artist.

Instead of becoming his girlfriend, Chiyo finds herself becoming his manga assistant, helping him draw romantic stories despite his complete lack of understanding of romance in real life.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A hilarious satire of the shoujo manga industry with exaggerated but relatable tropes.
  • Strong ensemble cast featuring quirky and lovable side characters.
  • Nozaki is the ultimate oblivious male lead, making the romance play out in comedic ways.


⭐ 9/10 – Laugh-out-loud funny, but don’t expect deep romance.


10. Hakushaku to Yousei (The Earl and the Fairy) (2008)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll, Funimation
🎭 Genre: Fantasy, Historical, Romance
📖 Episodes: 12

Hakushaku to Yousei

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

If you love Victorian-era romance with a supernatural twist, this criminally underrated anime is for you. 

Lydia Carlton, a young woman known as a Fairy Doctor, has the rare ability to see and communicate with fairies

When she meets Edgar J.C. Ashenbert, a mysterious nobleman claiming to be the legendary “Blue Knight Earl”, she is thrown into a whirlwind of romance, mystery, and adventure.

The chemistry between Lydia and Edgar is a perfect blend of tension and charm, Edgar is flirtatious but hides a tragic past, while Lydia is wary of his intentions. 

The story is dripping with gothic romance vibes, making it feel like a fantasy novel brought to life.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A beautifully crafted historical fantasy setting inspired by European folklore.
  • A strong, independent heroine who isn’t easily swooned by the charming male lead.
  • The blend of romance, supernatural elements, and mystery keeps things exciting.


⭐ 8.5/10 – Perfect for fans of Black Butler or Howl’s Moving Castle.


11. The Ice Guy and His Cool Female Colleague (2023)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll
🎭 Genre: Romantic Comedy, Supernatural, Workplace Romance
📖 Episodes: 12

The Ice Guy and His Cool Female Colleague

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

A wholesome office romance with a supernatural twist? Yes, please! The Ice Guy and His Cool Female Colleague introduces Himuro, a young man who is a descendant of a snow spirit.

Whenever he gets too flustered or emotional, he unintentionally creates snowstorms, blizzards, or even ice sculptures.

His biggest weakness? His new coworker Fuyutsuki, a kind, elegant woman who remains calm and collected in every situation, making Himuro fall for her even harder.

Their interactions are awkward, heartwarming, and full of soft, romantic tension.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A rare blend of supernatural and workplace romance, think My Senpai is Annoying meets Your Name.
  • Adorable, slow-burn relationship with lots of wholesome moments.
  • Himuro is one of the most relatable male leads, awkward, hopelessly in love, and just trying his best.


⭐ 8.5/10 – A sweet and refreshing take on office romance anime.


12. Inu X Boku SS (2012)

📺 Where to Watch: Amazon Prime Video
🎭 Genre: Supernatural, Romance, Comedy
📖 Episodes: 12 + 1 OVA

Inu X Boku SS

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Inu X Boku SS takes the bodyguard romance trope and adds a supernatural twist.

Ririchiyo Shirakiin, a socially awkward rich girl, moves into a high-security apartment complex where every resident is a descendant of a yokai (spirit/demon).

Each resident is assigned a Secret Service bodyguard, and Ririchiyo is paired with Soushi Miketsukami, a fox spirit who is hopelessly devoted to her

But beneath his charming and overly obedient demeanor, Soushi hides a dark and complex past, making their relationship deeply emotional.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A perfect mix of romance, comedy, and supernatural intrigue.
  • Soushi is one of anime’s most devoted male leads, but his devotion hides a painful backstory.
  • Ririchiyo’s character growth, from emotionally closed-off to vulnerable, is beautifully written.


⭐ 9/10 – A romantic fantasy with heart-wrenching emotional depth.


13. Itsudatte Bokura no Koi wa 10 cm Datta (Our Love Has Always Been 10cm Apart) (2017)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll
🎭 Genre: Romance, Drama, School Life
📖 Episodes: 6

Itsudatte Bokura no Koi wa 10 cm Datta

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Some love stories aren’t about dramatic confessions or intense love triangles, they’re about missed chances, subtle moments, and unspoken feelings

Our Love Has Always Been 10cm Apart perfectly captures the pain and beauty of a relationship that teeters on the edge of friendship and romance.

Miou Aida and Haruki Serizawa have been inseparable since their first year of high school

They laugh together, support each other, and share a deep connection, but for some reason, that last 10 centimeters between them never seems to close.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A painfully relatable “almost lovers” story, perfect for fans of slow-burn romance.
  • Gorgeous, emotional storytelling with a nostalgic, coming-of-age feel.
  • Music plays a major role, as the anime is based on a series of Vocaloid songs by HoneyWorks.


⭐ 8.5/10 – A beautiful and emotional romance for fans of Your Lie in April.


14. Kakuriyo no Yadomeshi (Kakuriyo – Bed & Breakfast for Spirits) (2018)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll, Funimation
🎭 Genre: Fantasy, Supernatural, Romance, Slice of Life
📖 Episodes: 26

Kakuriyo no Yadomeshi

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

What if you were kidnapped by an ogre and told you had to marry him to pay off your grandfather’s debt?

That’s the situation Aoi Tsubaki finds herself in, but instead of giving in, she chooses to work at a spirit-world inn to earn her freedom.

Rather than focusing on romance right away, Kakuriyo no Yadomeshi builds a cozy, atmospheric world filled with Japanese folklore, delicious food, and a slow-burning relationship between Aoi and her ogre “fiancé” Odanna.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A mix of romance and food anime, giving it a relaxing and immersive feel.
  • The yokai (spirit) world is beautifully designed, with stunning visuals and folklore elements.
  • Aoi is a strong-willed, independent heroine who isn’t just waiting to be saved.


⭐ 8.5/10 – A charming blend of fantasy, food, and romance.


15. Kimi to Boku no Saigo no Senjou, Aruiwa Sekai ga Hajimaru Seisen (Our Last Crusade or the Rise of a New World) (2020)

📺 Where to Watch: Funimation, Hulu
🎭 Genre: Action, Fantasy, Romance
📖 Episodes: 24 (2 seasons)

Kimi to Boku no Saigo no Senjou, Aruiwa Sekai ga Hajimaru Seisen

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Love stories about rival factions and forbidden romance always carry a dramatic flair, and Our Last Crusade or the Rise of a New World delivers just that.

It follows Iska, a swordsman from the Empire, and Aliceliese, a witch princess from the Nebulis Sovereignty, two warriors destined to be enemies, yet drawn to each other in ways they can’t ignore.

If you love the star-crossed lovers trope with epic battles and political intrigue, this anime brings high-stakes action mixed with tender romantic moments.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A perfect blend of romance, action, and fantasy, making it engaging for multiple genres.
  • Enemies-to-lovers done right, Iska and Alice have undeniable chemistry.
  • A mix of magic and advanced technology, creating a unique world-building experience.


⭐ 8/10 – A high-energy romance with stunning visuals and great world-building.


16. Koi to Yobu ni wa Kimochi Warui (Koikimo) (2021)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll
🎭 Genre: Romantic Comedy, Drama
📖 Episodes: 12

Koi to Yobu ni wa Kimochi Warui

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

This one is controversial, unconventional, and undeniably unique.

Koikimo follows Ryo Amakusa, a suave but emotionally detached businessman, who falls in love with Ichika Arima, a high school girl who saved him from falling down the stairs.

The twist? Ichika wants absolutely nothing to do with him.

Despite Ryo’s persistent (and often cringeworthy) romantic gestures, Ichika constantly rejects him, making for a dynamic that’s both uncomfortable and surprisingly heartfelt as Ryo learns how to respect boundaries and develop genuine feelings.

What Makes It Unique?

  • An age-gap romance that’s fully aware of its awkwardness.
  • Ichika is a great female lead, she never falls for Ryo’s advances without real emotional development.
  • A hilarious mix of misunderstandings, drama, and actual character growth.


⭐ 7.5/10 – Weirdly endearing, but be ready for secondhand embarrassment!


17. Kokoro Connect (2012)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll, HIDIVE
🎭 Genre: Supernatural, Drama, Romance
📖 Episodes: 17 (13 + 4 OVA)

Kokoro Connect

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

What if you suddenly started randomly swapping bodies with your friends? Sounds fun at first, until it starts revealing deeply buried secrets, personal trauma, and hidden feelings.

Kokoro Connect is more than just a supernatural gimmick; it’s a beautifully written psychological drama that explores identity, emotions, and human connection.

Among its five main characters, unspoken love and complicated friendships create some of the most emotionally raw moments in romance anime. Instead of a straightforward love story, this anime dives deep into human psychology and relationships.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A supernatural romance with a strong emotional core.
  • Deep character development, every character has a painful, relatable struggle.
  • The romance unfolds naturally through shared vulnerability and hardships.


⭐ 9/10 – A must-watch for fans of psychological drama with a touch of romance.


18. Meiji Tokyo Renka (2019)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll
🎭 Genre: Historical, Supernatural, Reverse Harem, Romance
📖 Episodes: 12

Meiji Tokyo Renka

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Imagine being accidentally transported back to the Meiji era and finding yourself surrounded by handsome, famous historical figures, all of whom seem unusually interested in you.

That’s the premise of Meiji Tokyo Renka, a time-travel romance where the protagonist, Mei Ayazuki, finds herself in the late 1800s with the ability to see spirits.

Though it follows some otome game tropes, the historical setting, supernatural elements, and surprisingly well-written romance make this one stand out. Mei’s romantic journey isn’t just about choosing a love interest, it’s about finding where she belongs.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A blend of historical fiction and supernatural romance.
  • Mei is a proactive heroine, not just a passive character waiting to be rescued.
  • The romantic options are based on real historical figures, making for a fascinating twist.


⭐ 8/10 – A charming, immersive romance with an interesting historical backdrop.


19. Midara na Ao-chan wa Benkyou ga Dekinai (Ao-chan Can’t Study!) (2019)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll
🎭 Genre: Romantic Comedy, Ecchi, School Life
📖 Episodes: 12

Midara na Ao-chan wa Benkyou ga Dekinai

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

Imagine being so embarrassed by your dad that it completely messes up your ability to focus on school, and romance.

Ao-chan Can’t Study! follows Ao Horie, the daughter of a famous erotic novelist, who is desperate to escape her father’s legacy and get into a prestigious university.

But things get complicated when the school’s most popular guy, Kijima, confesses his feelings for her.

Now, instead of focusing on studying, Ao’s mind is full of hilarious and awkward misunderstandings about romance.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A fresh twist on the classic “studious girl vs. love” trope.
  • A hilarious mix of comedy, romance, and embarrassment, Ao’s internal monologue is pure gold.
  • Kijima isn’t just a stereotypical “cool guy” love interest, he’s genuinely sweet and caring.


⭐ 8/10 – Funny, charming, and relatable for anyone who’s ever been embarrassed by their parents.


20. I’m Giving the Disgraced Noble Lady I Rescued a Crash Course in Naughtiness (2023)

📺 Where to Watch: HIDIVE
🎭 Genre: Fantasy, Comedy, Romance
📖 Episodes: 12

I'm Giving the Disgraced Noble Lady I Rescued a Crash Course in Naughtiness

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

The title might sound scandalous, but don’t be fooled, I’m Giving the Disgraced Noble Lady I Rescued a Crash Course in Naughtiness is one of the most unexpectedly wholesome romance anime in recent years.

It follows Allen, a successful merchant who rescues Charlotte, a noblewoman falsely accused and cast out of high society.

Instead of seeking revenge, Charlotte slowly rebuilds her life with Allen’s support, learning how to live freely, have fun, and embrace love.

What Makes It Unique?

  • A fresh take on the “fallen noblewoman” trope, with a focus on healing and self-discovery.
  • Allen is a unique male lead, caring, supportive, and genuinely respects Charlotte’s independence.
  • Romantic comedy elements mix well with deeper themes of self-worth and new beginnings.


⭐ 8.5/10 – A feel-good love story with plenty of charm and humor.


21. Sasaki to Miyano (Sasaki and Miyano) (2022)

📺 Where to Watch: Crunchyroll, Funimation
🎭 Genre: BL (Boys’ Love), Slice of Life, Romance
📖 Episodes: 12

Sasaki to Miyano

Why It’s a Hidden Gem

BL romance anime are often filled with dramatic tension and unrealistic relationships, but Sasaki and Miyano takes a refreshing, wholesome approach.

This anime tells the gentle, slow-burn romance between Sasaki, a rebellious upperclassman, and Miyano, a shy, self-proclaimed fujoshi who loves BL manga but never imagined he’d be in a love story himself.

Instead of relying on over-the-top drama or forced conflicts, this anime focuses on self-discovery, mutual respect, and gradual emotional development.

What Makes It Unique?

  • One of the most wholesome and well-paced BL romances, no forced drama.
  • Miyano’s internal struggle with his feelings is portrayed realistically and thoughtfully.
  • Soft, pastel aesthetics and a relaxing atmosphere make it a great comfort watch.


⭐ 9/10 – A beautifully written, feel-good love story.


Love Stories Beyond the Mainstream

Romance anime comes in many shapes and forms, from heartwarming slow burns to high-stakes fantasy love stories, and even quirky, comedic romances that break the mold

The 21 anime on this list prove that great love stories don’t always get the recognition they deserve.

Whether it’s the wholesome friendship-turned-romance of Sasaki and Miyano, the supernatural intrigue of Kakuriyo no Yadomeshi, or the hilarious misunderstandings in Ao-chan Can’t Study!, each of these hidden gems brings something fresh and unforgettable to the genre.

Your Turn! Let’s Talk Romance Anime

Now, I want to hear from you!

  • Have you watched any of these underrated romance anime? Which ones are your favorites?
  • Are there any other hidden gems that deserve a spot on this list?

Drop your thoughts in the comments below! Let’s share recommendations, discover new favorites, and celebrate the beauty of romance anime together.

Want More Anime Recommendations?

If you love discovering hidden anime gems, make sure to follow for more anime lists, reviews, and recommendations. Whether you’re looking for the next must-watch romance or something completely different, I’ve got you covered!

Ready to dive into your next romance anime binge? Grab some snacks, get cozy, and let the love stories begin!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply